An ambitious project aimed at encouraging Limburg fruit growers to switch to viticulture, the cultivation of grapes for wine production and table consumption, is struggling with large surpluses and stagnant sales. The project’s initiator, Professor Ghislain Houben, remains firmly convinced of the merits of his model using hybrid grape varieties, but the participating growers are feeling economic pressure. The Limburg wine sector is hit by the effects of a global decline in consumption.
Limburg fruit growers are left with a surplus of grapes due to sluggish wine sales
Six years ago, the idea seemed like a golden opportunity: when Russia restricted imports of Limburg pears, Professor of Economics Ghislain Houben (Hasselt University / Jerom’s Winery / Hoenshof) persuaded a group of local fruit growers to clear part of their orchards. The growers switched to viticulture using sustainable hybrid grape varieties (PIWIs), which are more resistant to disease and yield higher volumes. However, what began as an ecological and economic alternative has hit a brick wall over the past two years.
Surplus stock is piling up and the expected sales through major supermarket chains such as Delhaize and Carrefour have stalled.
Belgian wine is first victim
“As a Belgian winemaker, you’re the first victim in the supermarket,” explains Stijn Avermaete, who, with 20 hectares, is the largest fruit grower affiliated to the consortium. “For supermarkets, it’s all about the figures, and the profit margin on Belgian wine is much smaller than on French or Spanish wines. What’s more, Colruyt has also planted its own vineyards. We’re now facing a structural surplus, but I still believe in the model. There’s no point in rushing to grub up the vines just yet.”
As well as distribution, quality and processing issues also play a part. Growers delivered their harvested grapes to Jerom’s Winery, where Houben’s sons carried out the processing.
“They’ve actually been too generous and accepted all the harvested grapes, even those of slightly lower quality,” explains fruit grower Jos Claes from Borgloon. “The sugar content wasn’t always optimal, and by mixing everything together, the result wasn’t always of the highest standard. That didn’t do the reputation any favours. But I don’t hold it against them.” Claes still has his grapes pressed at Jerom’s Winery but has now chosen to sell his wine directly himself.
Another grower involved, who wishes to remain anonymous, draws a matter-of-fact conclusion: “The economic model isn’t working at the moment. We haven’t recouped our investment yet. But taking risks is simply part and parcel of being a fruit grower; with new apple varieties, it doesn’t always work out first time either.”
Lack of national pride
Despite the tensions, founder Ghislain Houben remains steadfastly committed to the concept. In his view, the cause lies in a combination of high Belgian production costs, strong foreign competition and a lack of national pride amongst Belgian consumers.
“Traditional wines are gradually reaching the end of their life cycle, and the government is forcing us towards more sustainable cultivation,” emphasises Houben. “Every day I believe more and more in hybrid grape varieties. They are genetically stronger, require less crop protection and fit into an ecological model.”
Houben regards the fact that hybrid wines still face an image problem as a teething phase: “In the Champagne region, companies have been building their reputation for six generations. Here in Belgium, we are still only the first generation. We still need to build that brand name by opting for originality and innovation, not by being copycats of traditional regions.”
Global pressure, established estates remain unscathed
The problems facing the fruit growers’ consortium are not entirely isolated. Wine consumption in general is under pressure worldwide: alcohol consumption is falling to its lowest level in 60 years, and young people’s drinking habits are changing.
Nevertheless, market saturation in Limburg is not affecting everyone equally. Older, established wine estates that have been building their brand for decades are barely feeling the impact of the market downturn.
“Time is needed for image and sustainability”
“Cheap bulk wines are under severe pressure, but for quality products with a story behind them and established family businesses, this is a fluctuation that we can easily absorb,” notes Joyce Van Rennes of Wijnkasteel Genoels-Elderen. Karel Henckens of the Aldeneyck wine estate in Maaseik also sees no decline in demand and is even planning to plant more vines: “If we want to move forward in Limburg, we must all focus on quality and identity rooted in our terroir (sense of the place), not on producing bulk wines” he says.